California’s paradoxical culture of individuality


How do shared influences shape what makes us different?
By MOLLY WILKINSON — arts@theaggie.org
From the legacy of 1960s counterculture to Hollywood’s influence on popular culture and Silicon Valley’s entrepreneurial futurism, California has long cultivated a mainstream cultural image of individuality, creativity and reinvention. In such a culture, how do media and cultural influences surrounding us shape what it means to be an individual in the first place?
Fourth-year mechanical engineering major Jesse Ryan Sandoz, who grew up in Southern California, reflected on how the state’s historical legacy and contemporary culture of innovation shaped his outlook.
“California has the technology and entertainment industries in Silicon Valley and in Los Angeles, respectively, but I think this idea originated from the Gold Rush,” Sandoz said. “This idea that California is a place where one small idea, one discovery, one stroke of luck can propel you to stratospheric heights, has influenced me to feel, from a young age, capable of greatness, or that greatness can be seized.”
UC Davis Professor of Communications Laramie Taylor considered how seeing others pursue aspirational paths can shape one’s own sense of possibility.
“I think one of the reasons that people don't do big ambitious things, like go to graduate school, try to become a doctor or lawyer, start their own creative endeavors, record that first album [or] write their first book is [due to] a crisis of imagination,” Taylor said. “If you grow up with stories about creative success around you, then I think it grants you license to dream those things and imagine more than [you] might in other places.”
From the coastal regions to the inland valleys, and from Northern to Southern California, it is nearly impossible to generalize such a diverse landscape. Taylor noted that a cultural identity centered on individuality and self-expression isn’t exclusive to California, and its enduring reputation is largely shaped by its most culturally prominent metropolitan areas rather than a shared statewide identity.
“To some extent, it's cities, and we just have some of the sexiest cities in the country,” Taylor said. “I think it’s a question of inertia and momentum. That’s the narrative that popped up and persists today, but the Central Valley probably would not identify with any of that.”
Owen Bickham, a third-year cinema and digital media major who grew up in Colorado, described how the pursuit of a distinct personal identity can become paradoxical when people draw from the same trends and aesthetics to distinguish themselves.
“It feels like, especially in Southern California and LA, where everyone postures like they're this very original character, but then you go to a flea market and look around, and it's the Instagram Panopticon,” Bickham said. “Everybody who engages in those trends and cultures looks the same and acts the same and is seeking the same aesthetic.”
Bickham’s observations raise questions about how people come to adopt the identities and aesthetics that they use to distinguish themselves. People’s identities develop largely in response to the world around them, according to Taylor.
“Our sense of self develops in conversation with the world around us, the people around us, the cultural moment we live in and that includes real people but also the mediated world,” Taylor said. “I'm a professor, father, husband, an American, a man and so forth. Each of these is like a discrete identity, and which of them informs my decisions and behaviors at any given time depends in part on the cues in my environment that signal which is appropriate, and the media does a lot of that too.”
Taylor said that these subidentities can fulfill two fundamental human desires, belonging and uniqueness.
“We want to feel a sense of belonging, and we also want to feel unique and special, and those two things live in tension with each other,” Taylor said. “Optimum Distinctiveness Theory says that we focus on different parts of our identity, and identify with different groups in order to strike the right balance. This proliferation of identities on social media makes that possible.”
If social media helps shape collective identities, what can happen when someone removes themselves from that environment? Sandoz describes an unexpected relationship with social media platforms after stepping away from them.
“I thought I would be more sure of myself, but I’m less,” Sandoz said. “I've realized I've lost the support system and community. I've lost validation, gratification, escapism and I'm faced more frequently with heavy philosophical questions and existential crises. I fear that I lack individuality. I don't know which thoughts are my own. Everything's really regurgitation. It's a sea of [recycled] thoughts, and there are islands of new thoughts being charted and rediscovered.”
Still, Sandoz recognizes the capacity to process and synthesize external information as an important aspect of human individuality.
“We're taking in information all the time, even if we're not consciously filtering it, and that's becoming part of us,” Sandoz said. “Our brain can synthesize conclusions from disparate pieces of information. I think this ability for synthesis is what makes human intelligence really unique and powerful.”
Bickham similarly pointed to the role of personal interpretation in maintaining individuality.
“When you're watching something, you're forming your own meaning and attributing your own ideas of what it means onto it,” Bickham said. “I've taken something different away from this media than the next person. I think that's kind of how individuality is retained.”
Taylor maintained that the media informs identity without fully determining it.
“The mistake would be to say, ‘Well, we're just whoever the media tells us to be,’” Taylor said. “It's not a question of our identities being written for us by external influences; it's that the shape our identities take is informed by everything around us, including but not limited to the media.”
For the state of California and its inhabitants, these distinctions leave room for
individuality within a broader cultural landscape. Its cultural narratives provide a starting point that influences how people understand themselves, but they don’t necessarily determine what people make of those influences.
Written by: Molly Wilkinson — arts@theaggie.org


