Personal attacks are no substitute for public service
.jpg&w=1920&q=75)
.jpg&w=1920&q=75)
Candidates in this year’s midterms weaponized opponents’ identities and personal histories — voters had more pressing concerns
By THE EDITORIAL BOARD — opinion@theaggie.org
At 6 a.m. Oct. 12, federal agents raided Minnesota Rep. Ilhan Omar’s house as part of an investigation into whether she or her late father committed immigration fraud during the citizenship process. According to Omar, the search lasted four to five hours, and agents seized 17 items including phones, notebooks, a camera and a children’s book of Somali phrases.
At an Ohio rally later that day, President Donald Trump directed a series of remarks at Omar and her country of origin, Somalia.
“She comes in from a country without laws, without police, without military, where all they do is shoot each other, and she comes into our country and she says, ‘I have a constitutional right,’” Trump said. “She’s telling us about the Constitution, and she comes from one of the worst countries anywhere on the planet.”
Chants of “deport” broke out among the audience.
At the same rally, Trump later turned his attention to Abdul El-Sayed, then-candidate for United States Senate in Michigan.
“You look at the guy running in Michigan,” Trump said. “He’s a jihadist.”
The crowd once again erupted into chants of “deport.”
Instances of politicians utilizing Islamophobic rhetoric in this year’s midterm cycle were not limited to this rally. On Oct. 25, Trump described El-Sayed as “the only senator that will have to go through a metal detector before he’s allowed to go into the Senate.”
Texas Governor Greg Abbott, in a last-minute gambit days before the election, accused his opponent, Gina Hinojosa, of supporting Sharia law because of her endorsement from the Council on American-Islamic Relations — Hinojosa is Catholic.
In Georgia, State Senator and candidate for Lieutenant Governor Greg Dolexal released a bizarre AI-generated ad depicting a sword-wielding figure destroying a man’s “Happy Easter” cake and a crowd of men dressed in Pashtun clothing firing rifles in the street. The video is set to a Sharia-themed parody of The Knack’s “My Sharona.” Its end card reads, “Keep Georgia Sharia Free.”
It was not just candidates’ ethnic and religious backgrounds which became fodder for political attacks this campaign season. In Ohio, gubernatorial candidate Vivek Ramaswamy ran an advertisement in which his opponent’s estranged mother described her as “a lifelong liar.”
Ramaswamy’s opponent, Amy Acton, was removed from her mother’s custody in 1978, when her stepfather was indicted by a grand jury on rape charges involving Acton, then 12 years old. After posting bond, he failed to show at a court hearing and remained a fugitive until his death in 2004. Acton’s mother remained married to him throughout this period, and has not had contact with Acton since the indictment, nearly 50 years ago.
From racial fearmongering to the weaponization of a candidate’s experience with childhood abuse, the Editorial Board condemns these vicious attacks on political opponents.
The lack of decorum displayed in this year’s midterm elections sets a dangerous precedent. Using threats of denaturalization and deportation as political cudgels undermines the fundamental democratic principle that opponents of the governing political party retain the same right to participate in American civic life as any other citizen.
Likewise, portraying a candidate’s experience with childhood sexual abuse as evidence that she is untrustworthy — “a lifelong liar” as the advertisement put it — is despicable, and sends a chilling message to the approximately one in four girls and one in 20 boys in the U.S. who experience childhood sexual abuse.
While the inflammatory and unnecessarily cruel rhetoric displayed in this year’s midterms warrants unequivocal condemnation, the results show that — as the rising cost of living remained at the forefront of voters’ minds — appeals to Islamophobia or attempts to discredit a survivor of childhood abuse were not enough to bolster electoral prospects.
El-Sayed won Michigan’s Senate race. Acton and Hinojosa won the governorships of Ohio and Texas, respectively. Omar was re-elected to Congress in her biggest electoral win since 2018.
As El-Sayed himself noted, personal attacks on candidates distract from the actual issues affecting voters’ daily lives.
“Donald Trump and JD Vance, their whole campaign, Mike Rogers’ whole campaign, is to point at me and my name and my faith,” El-Sayed said. “But my name and my faith are not the reason you can’t afford your gas. My name and my faith are not the reason you can’t afford your groceries. My name and my faith are not the reason you can’t see a doctor.”
This election served as a reminder that despite the theatrics of modern politics, cheap appeals to racism or attacks on opponents’ personal lives will never be a substitute for the actual labor of public service: listening to constituents and addressing their concerns. And as this midterm showed, the American people’s concerns are not where someone comes from, but what they do for the communities they represent.
Written by: The Editorial Board — opinion@theaggie.org


