53.2 F
Davis

Davis, California

Thursday, December 25, 2025
Home Blog Page 1644

Variations on a Theme

0

The beginning of the year always prompts a time of promise for the year to come and stuff like that. For me and many others, this manifests itself in the form of half-arsed New Year’s resolutions, mine of which either tend to be overly pragmatic (i.e. floss regularly, drink more water, get more rest) to downright unfeasible (be taller, get perfect vision, stop procrastinating).

Besides, eight days into the new year hasn’t completely converted me into a believer of 2009, even with the help of my nifty new Moleskine planner. Also, I’m still catching up on everyone else’s year-end lists with all the things that I apparently missed out on last year. That being said, partly inspired by The A.V. Club’s Dec. 5 article “Art We’ve Resisted,” I present to you my own list of trends I’ve “resisted” in 2008.

Twilight. The timeless tale of an abstinent vampire and his human girlfriend has made even the most reluctant of readers into diehard fans. And when the immensely popular book series (which was touted by some to be the next Harry Potter) came to life on the silver screen late last year, the mania grew: Twilight merchandise took over local malls, an English actor named Robert Pattinson became famous for being pale and having funny hair and the debate of vampires versus zombies and who is cooler became the new ninjas versus pirates argument.

Fixed gear bicycles. Truth be told, I know nothing about the mechanics of bikes, let alone fixed gear ones. In fact, the only way I can tell fixies apart from the common bike is lack of brakes and their flashy aesthetics. So when the fixie frenzy swept through our own bicycle-loving town, imagine how uncool (not to mention, slow) I felt as a mere pedestrian walking on campus. Love ’em or hate ’em, you have to admit that these fixie kids look nowhere near as obnoxious as the guy who rides the unicycle to class. (Just kidding, Unicycle Kid!)

“Mad Men.” There always seems to be that one critically acclaimed show that I just somehow never get around to seeing, and last year’s list of shows to watch included “Mad Men,” “Dexter” and “Californication.” Nope, I spent a large portion of 2008 watching true television gems like “The Hills” and “Jon and Kate Plus 8” instead.

Of course, no one is completely immune to the trendsetting agendas of the industry, and 2008 presented a couple of weaknesses that I succumbed to.

American Apparel. That slightly overpriced line of basics that has strung a chord with hipsters around the world – at first I scoffed. Eighteen dollars for a plain-Jane T-shirt, even if it was produced through sweatshop-free means? No thanks.

But alas, here I am, 12 months and a couple of shirts, three dresses, a skirt and a sweatshirt later. Maybe it’s the fact that they were named the number two Top Trendsetting Brand by trend and market research firm Intelligence Group, or the fact that AA creative director Dov Charney was awarded honors as “Retailer of the Year” at the Michael Awards for the Fashion Industry. Yeah, that’s probably why.

Frozen yogurt. Last year marked the opening of the third frozen yogurt joint in Davis, all each within less than a half mile of one another. The evidence stands: 2008 was a good year for my favorite frozen treat. But really, what’s not to love? It’s healthy, it’s delicious and it lends itself perfectly to clipped terms like “fro-yo” or “frogurt” – and if there’s our generation loves, it’s a supe abbrev.

 

RACHEL FILIPINAS thinks 2009 would be a lot better with more e-mails from you guys, and maybe for her wisdom teeth to finally grow in so she doesn’t have to worry about it any more. She can be reached at rmfilipinas@ucdavis.edu.

Artsweek

0

MUSIC

Beneath the Rapture, The Fall of Autumn, The Shotgun Effect, Light in August, Hello Sailor

Today, 8 p.m., $10 in advance

The Boardwalk in Orangevale

Not to seem entirely sacrilegious, but I’ve never understood the appeal of Christian rock, let alone Christian metal. Perhaps the actual hardcore aspect of bands like The Fall of Autumn and The Shotgun Effect will distract me of the whole godly, finding a higher power purpose of their musical endeavors.

 

T.O.P., Tais, The Foulmouths, Ruby Ibarra

Friday, 8 p.m., $5

Delta of Venus

One of my New Year’s resolutions was to add a bit more hip-hop to my musical agenda, so imagine my delight at this line-up, which features the best and brightest of Sacramento’s rap scene. Well, at least there’s one resolution that looks to be more promising than my other one to work out at the ARC more often.

 

Hero’s Last Mission, Early States, Fate Under Fire, Lynus, Fashion City Scandal

Friday, 8 p.m., $10 in advance

The Boardwalk in Orangevale

Roseville-based band Early States was named one of theTop 21 Unsigned Bands of 2008 by PureVolume.com. Take a sprinkling of piano-playing and a dollop of emotional songwriting, and you got yourself a stew of melodious indie pop a la Copeland and Augustana.

 

Ricky Berger, Chelsea Wolfe, Tippy Canoe, Blue Rabbit

Friday, 8 p.m., $6

Luna’s Café & Juice Bar in Sacramento

Ricky Berger and Chelsea Wolfe are already household names in the Sactown music scene, but I’m sure that Sacramento can make room for San Francisco-based band Blue Rabbit. Cello and harp-infused melodies act as a perfect accompaniment to the eerie yet soothing lullabies of lead vocalist Heather Anderson.

 

The Definite Articles, Silian Rail, J. Irvin Dally

Saturday, 8 p.m., $3 to $5

Fish and Sam’s House (L Street & Covell)

If you haven’t heard of Silian Rail, be sure to make that one of your New Year’s resolutions. The Oakland/San Francisco band takes the cake when it comes to intricate and infinitely interesting instrumentationfor a sneak preview, think of the complex arrangements of other post-rock acts like Minus the Bear, From Monument to Masses and Tera Melos.

 

Willie Nelson

Sunday, 7 p.m., $25 with a student ID, $50 general admission

Jackson Hall

Willie Nelson’s an American icon, and this red-headed stranger has a lot up his sleeve. On one hand, he’s an eccentric, pot-smoking old man. On the other hand, he’s a Grammy-winningcowboy-hippie troubadourwith a movie career on the side. Sounds like your everyday triple threat to me.

 

Limbeck, The New Trust, Push Push Pull

Wednesday, 7:30 p.m.

UC Davis Coffee House

Another New Year’s resolution of mine: Spend less money. Seeing as this show is free and a little pop-punk is always a good way to perk up any dreary Wednesday, I’ll be sure to reserve a spot for myself on the Coho floor.

 

AT THE MOVIES

Slumdog Millionaire

Open now at the Varsity Theatre on Second Street

I’ve always wanted to participate in a game show, but hope I would never have to face the same fate as the film’s main character, who is accused of cheating after he wins. For one opinion of the film, check out page __.

 

Macaframa

Friday, 9 p.m. at Crest Theatre in Sacramento

Fixies have taken over the roads, and now they’re looking to the silver screen. For more information, see page __.

 

 

ART / THEATER

“All About UsOpening Reception

Friday, 7 p.m.

Tsao Gallery at the Davis Art Center (1919 F Street)

Sadly, I left 2008 with several art projects unfinished, so I’m looking to kick this year off right. Thus, I’m turning to the locals for inspiration:All About Us features works from past and present Davis Art Center teachers, students and board members.

 

Hello, Dolly!

Friday and Saturday, 8:15 p.m. and Sunday at 2:25 p.m., $18 general admission, $16 with a student ID

607 Pena Drive

Presented by the Davis Musical Theater Company, this musical tells the tale of a brassy widow named Dolly and all of her exploits as a meddling matchmaker.

 

RACHEL FILIPINAS can be reached at arts@theaggie.org. 

 

 

Science Scene

“Third-hand smoke” is also a threa

Experts have identified a new health threat from cigarettes: an invisible and toxic combination of gasses and particles labeled as “third-hand smoke” that persist long after second-hand smoke has cleared.

The toxins cling on smokers’ hair and clothes, as well as in carpeting and furniture.

The study, published in this month’s issue of Pediatrics, especially focuses on the toxins’ effects on child and infant health. Researchers say children can possibly ingest the toxins, especially while crawling on the floor.

Researchers say the study has new implications for behavior, as it shows simply shutting a door does not shield kids from the harmful effects of the smoke.

Third-hand smoke includes materials such as hydrogen cyanide which is used in chemical weapons, butane which is used in lighter fluid, arsenic and lead. Eleven of the compounds in third-hand smoke are highly carcinogenic and are cancer risks for people of any age.

(Source: nytimes.com)

Bedbugs bite in Ohio

Cincinnati, Ohio has seen an alarming rise in the pest Cimex lectularius, commonly known as bedbugs.

Although the bugs were thought to have vanished in the 1950s because of the use of DDT and other pesticides, a recent public survey found that one in six residents of Cincinnati have had an encounter with bedbugs within the last year.

Reports of bedbugs in the city started about three years ago, but officials thought it was an abnormality, not a trend.

City officials say they expect the problem to get worse. If the occurrence of the pests increases, city officials say they won’t be able to keep up with inspections.

The complaints don’t stop in Ohio. Reports of the bugs are coming from college campuses, high-end hotels and movie theaters nationwide.

Adult bedbugs are reddish brown in color and about a quarter of an inch long. They tend to be mostly active at night, and hide in mattresses or behind furniture during the day. Their bites leave itchy marks on the skin.

Killing the bugs can be a challenge, and in many cases numerous treatments by a professional exterminator are needed to eliminate the problem.

Entomologists say it is difficult to figure out the extent of the problem nationwide. What adds to the problem is that many cities suffering from current financial difficulties don’t see the bugs as a public health priority, as they don’t carry disease such as mosquitoes or cockroaches.

Reasons cited for an increase in the bugs include the ban of DDT and an increase in international travel.

(Source: latimes.com)

Study links control of blood sugar and memory decline

Researchers at Columbia University Medical Center say rises in blood sugar (glucose) can negatively impact memory by affecting the dentate gyrus, an area of the hippocampus that helps form memories.

The effects can be seen, researchers say, even when glucose rates are just moderately raised. This may explain the normal cognitive decline that comes with aging, as glucose regulation worsens with age.

The researchers used MRIs to map out brain regions in 240 elderly test subjects. A correlation was found between spiked glucose rates and reduced blood flow in the dentate gyrus, an indicator of reduced functions and activity in that area of the brain.

If decline in memory is the result of glucose regulation, then the issue affects everyone, researchers say. Exercise is recommended to help combat the issue, as glucose regulation is improved with physical activity.

(Source: nytimes.com)

SCIENCE SCENE was compiled by ANNA OPALKA. She can be reached at features@theaggie.org.

Two UC Davis Researchers Receive Stem Cell Funding

Two UC Davis School of Medicine researchers received funding for stem cell research from the California Institute for Regenerative Medicine (CIRM) earlier last month.

Kit Lam, professor of medicine and chief of the division of oncology and hematology, and Alice Tarantal, professor of pediatrics and director of the Center of Excellence in Translational Human Stem Cell Research, were among two dozen scientists to receive research funding under the new CIRM Tools and Technologies Awards. Both were awarded $835,540 and $842,149 respectively to fund investigation for the next two years looking into new techniques and capabilities for stem cells or improve already existing techniques.

Stem cells are undifferentiated cells found in either an embryo or among organs and tissues in adults. The potential of these cells lies in their unique properties. Unlike other cells found in the body, they do not have a specific function and can be manipulated to perform certain functions.

Lam’s research mostly involves discovering a way to track cancer cells in the human body.

“The main focus of my laboratory is to apply combinatorial chemistry to address a variety of biomedical problems,” said Lam in an e-mail. “These include the development of therapeutic and imaging agents against cancers, Alzheimer disease, and autoimmune diseases.”

Lam specifically uses the technique he developed as a junior faculty at the University of Arizona, the One-Bead-One-Compound (OBOC) combinatorial library method.

Lam plans on using this technique to discover synthetic molecules that will bind to the unique protein receptors on the surface of the stem cell. This will allow researchers to develop a tracer that can be used by other researchers such as Tarantal to track where the stem cell is in the body.

Building on Lam’s work, Tarantal’s research involves the next step -the process of tracking the stem cell with the use of positron emission tomography (PET). The PET scan requires a radioactive molecule, usually radioactive glucose, to be inserted into the body, which can be seen as the body breaks down the glucose to use as energy.

Her focus is on making the PET scanner sensitive to the point that it can detect the specially tagged stem cells and track them in the body.

Tarantal’s research is necessary if stem cells will be used as therapy for many different diseases in the near future.

“It is important to know where these [stem] cells go, what they are doing and whether the cell population is expanding as this will have a direct bearing on the success of a therapy,” said Simon Cherry, professor and chair of the department of biomedical engineering who will be working with Tarantal and the PET scanner. “Imaging is an ideal tool, as it can look non-invasively throughout the body to see these cells.”

Cherry believes that the PET scanner will play a vital role as a tracking technology for stem cells. There are two possibilities for trackers that can be used. One possibility is to tag the cells with some radioactive molecule that can be traced in the body. However, this will only last for a few days. The other, long-term option is to genetically modify the stem cell in order for it to express a so-called imaging reporter gene, which can make the cell somewhat radioactive once it recognizes certain molecules that were inserted into the body.

Not only are Tarantal and Lam part of the promising goal of using stem cells for treatment purpose, but UC Davis is also a leader in advancing research into the field. Supported by the California Institute for Regenerative Medicine, the UC Davis Institute for Regenerative Cures will be housed in the Sacramento campus, according to the UC Davis Medical Center’s website.

The institute plans on continuing the research into stem cells as possible treatments for various diseases including liver disease, blindness, HIV/AIDS, cancer and diabetes. UC Davis plans to launch a series of clinical trials once the facility is completed that focus on retinal occlusion, heart attacks, peripheral vascular disease and Huntington’s disease.

 

NICK MARKWITH can be reached at features@theaggie.org.

Pollution legacy slashing survival of San Francisco Estuary fish

A toxic mix of pesticides and industrial chemicals polluting the San Francisco Estuary is contributing to a downward spiral in fish populations by affecting the earliest stages of growth and development, according to a recent UC Davis study published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

 

The San Francisco Estuary connects the San Joaquin and Sacramento Rivers to the Pacific Ocean and includes both the Delta and San Francisco Bay.

 

Although several estuary fish species populations have been declining since the 1970s, record lows in recent years fly in the face of weather and river conditions that typically reverse these losses, according to the latest CALFED report on the subject.

 

The intensified decline reflects the estuary ecosystem’s cumulative response to various stresses including water flow diversions, invasive species and pollution, said lead study author David Ostrach, a research scientist at the UC Davis Center for Watershed Sciences.

 

Ostrach’s study showed that the offspring of striped bass – a model indicator of overall estuary health – are exposed to dangerous levels of contaminants passed on from the mother through eggs.

 

Past studies showed that the vast majority of river-collected progeny die shortly after hatching, while fish that survive to adulthood with contaminant exposure have higher incidences of disease, Ostrach said.

 

“The focus on effects in early life stages is appropriate because early development is highly sensitive to mutagenic pollutants,” said Ben Greenfield, an environmental scientist at the San Francisco Estuary Institute who was not involved in the study.

 

Researchers found significantly higher levels of contaminants in eggs from river bass compared to those from bass that were raised and bred in a hatchery with clean water. The list of elevated chemicals includes both discontinued and currently used pesticides, as well as PBCs and PBDEs, widely used organic compounds that have been shown to disrupt hormone balance and function and to cause permanent behavioral defects in mice.

 

To follow possible exposure effects on developing bass hatchlings (larvae), Ostrach used a novel approach to examine growth, organ formation and signs of health. Compared to their hatchery counterparts, river-raised larvae were deformed, grew slower, had stunted brain development and dysfunctional livers, and lacked enough energy stores to fuel their search for food.

 

“The majority of larvae would not make it to first feeding due to the developmental problems caused by the contaminants the mother fish is passing on to them,” Ostrach said.

 

In contrast to studies showing effects of a single to a few chemicals on fish development, our study clearly shows that a real world mix of contaminants is causing developmental problems, he said.

 

“These types of studies of conditions in the field are more difficult to perform than controlled laboratory experiments,” Greenfield said. “But they … often yield the most important results for managers.”

 

Further studies will examine the overall health of the striped bass population at all life stages and how problems might relate to other declining fish species in the Estuary, Ostrach said. The goal will be to provide conclusive data so that actions can be taken to mitigate some of the problems.

 

“These fish are being exposed to a lot of things that are a result of our human environment,” Ostrach said. “So to use them as a parallel model [regarding human health implications] is not unreasonable.”

 

PBDE levels in San Francisco Bay Area women’s breast milk are 100 times higher than elsewhere, indicating that humans are similarly accumulating the compounds and passing them on to children.

 

“In my opinion, more work by agencies, research scientists and the public needs to be addressing these contaminant issues … to seriously look at what is being [produced and] dumped into the environment … and to try and curtail that as well as to clean up the environment,” Ostrach said.

 

ELAINE HSIA can be reached at features@theaggie.org.

 

Upcoming Seminars

Today

 

UC Davis Master of Public Health (MPH) Admissions Information Night

Stephen A. McCurdy, Director of UC Davis MPH Program

7 to 8:30 p.m., MU II, Memorial Union

Sponsored by Public Health Services

 

Tomorrow

 

Action Video Game Playing Enhances Vision and Perceptual Decision Making

Daphne Bavelier

4 to 5 p.m., Center for Neuroscience, 1544 Newton Court, Research Park

Sponsored by the Center for Neuroscience

 

Where Mechanics and Biochemistry Meet: Dynamics of Cell Polarization in the Early C. elegans Embryo

Ed Munro- University of Washington, Friday Harbor

4:10 to 5:00 p.m., 1022 Life Sciences Building

Sponsored by College of Biological Sciences, Graduate Groups in Biochemistry & Molecular Biology and Cell & Developmental Biology, Section of Microbiology, Section of Molecular & Cellular Biology, Departments of Biological Chemistry and Cell Biology & Human Anatomy, the Molecular & Cellular Biology Training Grant (NIH), and the Howard Hughes Medical Institute.

 

 

Friday, Jan. 9

 

Center for Visual Sciences Vision Research Symposium

Trevor Lamb – Australian National University; Andrew Mariani, National Eye Institute

8:30 a.m. to 6 p.m., Center for Neuroscience/Center for Visual Sciences, 1544 Newton Court, Davis

Sponsored by the Center for Visual Sciences

 

Monday, Jan. 12

 

Epidemiology and Management of Invasive Phytophthora species in UK Woodlands

Elizabeth Fichtner – UC Davis

10 a.m. to 10:50 p.m.; 115 Hutchison Hall

Sponsored by plant pathology

 

Structure and Evolution of an Embryonic Cell Specification Pathway in Caenorhabditis elegans

Morris Maduro – UC Riverside

4:10 to 5 p.m.; 102 Hutchison Hall

Sponsored by nematology

 

 

More seminars can be found at calendar.ucdavis.edu. If you’d like to publish a seminar here, send an e-mail to features@theaggie.org.

DNA of UCD: Jonathan Eisen

If you’ve ever wondered if a certain drug would make that biology lab class a little more bearable, you’re not alone. Evolutionary biologist and UCD professor Jonathan Eisen found the prospect all too entertaining, producing a fake study on the issue as an April fool’s joke.

But when he’s not pulling pranks on the science community he manages to delve into the microscopic world of evolution and ecology offering both the community and his students a diverse and broad width of knowledge.

 

What do you teach at UC Davis?

This year I co-taught the first offering of BIS2C, the third quarter in the new Introductory Biology series. After two years working on the design of this course it was good to finally get it taught. I will be teaching this again next fall.

In addition, I teach an upper level course on microbial evolution which was offered as an EVE198 class and will probably have a new EVE number next time it is offered. Also I give some lectures for some medical microbiology and immunology classes here and there, as I have a split appointment between EVE and MMI.

 

And what do you research here?

I study how microbes evolve new functions and how we can use that knowledge to understand how microbes function in the world around us. Most of the time I study this by sequencing the genomes of microbes and then using computational methods to analyze the genome data. I am particularly interested in two specific scientific topics these days: how microbes survive and thrive in extreme environments and how microbes function as symbionts of animals.

 

What did you study in college?

Initially, I was an East Asian Studies major (at Harvard) with a background interest in biology. Then I took a cool introductory course on evolution from Stephen Jay Gould, a famous evolutionary biologist, and I switched to a biology major with a focus on evolution and ecology.

After working for a year in the lab I had worked in as an undergraduate, I then went to do my Ph.D. at Stanford in biological sciences. Initially I worked on butterfly population biology, but I switched to studying how mutations originate and how differences in mutation processes between species affect how those species evolve. I dabbled in studying genomes of microbes then and once I got my Ph.D., I got a faculty job at the place that helped launch the field of genomics (The Institute for Genomic Research).

 

What is the most interesting aspect of science you have studied?

Being the first person to glimpse the entire genetic make up of a particular species was and still is a thrill.

 

What is your favorite ecosystem?

Hydrothermal vents in the bottom of the ocean where the entire ecosystem is based on chemical energy (in contrast to the surface where most ecosystems are based on light energy).

 

What example of symbiosis do you find most fascinating?

I think the most fascinating aspect is how organisms are able to colonize new habitats simply by engaging in symbioses with other organisms rather than inventing new functions themselves. This is what allows lots of animals to survive on cellulose (e.g., cows), what allows plants to photosynthesize and what allows many species in the bottom of the ocean to survive without eating.

 

Do you think humans have evolved to their full potential? If not, how could we improve?

Evolution continues for all species, all the time. It never stops. As for potential, that depends on what one’s goals are. So sure, if you think humans should be faster, I am sure that one could conceive of a way to evolve humans to be faster. But that would likely be unethical and probably silly.

 

I think the most interesting thing about humans is that in addition to genetic evolution, we have cultural evolution and therefore we can supplement our genetic potential or limitations with other things. I for one am highly supplemental thanks to cultural evolution with glasses, lots of possessions and insulin. I probably could survive without the possessions, possibly survive without the glasses, but I would be dead without the insulin.

 

We have lots and lots of problems in the world. They are not going to be solved by genetic changes, but instead by cultural ones.

 

Other than what you learned in school, what tool or piece of information do you use most in your line of work?

Computers computers computers.

 

Tell us about that April fool’s prank …

I have always been a prankster. I have been [pulling pranks] for years.

 

Last year[2007], in a fit of hacking on the evening of Mar. 31, I made a fake New York Times article about [one of my colleagues] Craig Venter which I then circulated by e-mail and it got distributed very widely and lots of people liked it. However, it did not become completely viral and I think this was because it was not posted on the web. So I schemed to do one this year[2008] which involved fully using the web, and I found the perfect place to plan this joke – I got invited to a meeting at Google HQ with a collection of top notch science journalists, scientists, engineers and science bloggers.

 

I thus began my conspiracy to have as many people as possible post entries on April 1 about the same fake story. The story would be a spoof of the doping controversies in cycling and baseball but do it for scientists. Initially we were going to say the same drugs used in cycling were being abused by scientists, but then we came up with the idea to say that “brain doping” was being outlawed by the US and EU governments and that there was a worldwide crackdown on cognitive enhancement.

 

Little did we know when we first planned this that brain doping was a real issue and though the government was not crackingdown on it yet, there were high level discussion about the problem. We decided to continue with the joke although in a way it was less funny because it was sort of close to reality.

 

In my mind, good pranks like this seem real when they happen and then are completely ludicrous in retrospect. So we planned our joke, and I even created a fake website for the World Anti-Brain Doping Authority (WABDA), and became viral with all sorts of people believing it.

 

Outside of the prank, do you think that scientists could actually benefit from any kind of drug?

I keep getting asked this. I think scientists get plenty from drugs already, like caffeine so there is certainly anecdotal evidence that drugs can help. But despite a lot of people apparently taking these other drugs to improve thinking, it is not clear if it really helps.

 

So I think it is possible drugs can help people do better science. But the data seems to be weak on which ones to take. And then you get into ethical questions, such as, if we compete for grants, is it fair to take drugs if they are not available to all?

 

What do you do when you aren’t teaching or doing research on campus?

Hanging out with my kids, Analia, who is almost 4 and Andres who is almost 2. They are the best things ever.

 

 

LAUREN STEUSSY can be reached at features@theaggie.org.

A view from the soapbox

0

 

Baby 2009 has only just been catapulted squealing into our arms and already her diaper is loaded and in need of a change. Time moves fast. Deadlines approach. Quandaries call out for resolution. Even if the problems we face haven’t changed – culture wars, environmental deterioration, undying greed – we can use this new year as an opportunity to look at them with new eyes.

The incompetent sleazebags of the Bush administration pat themselves on the back for a world well-plundered as Bush himself designs last-minute legislation under the radar to make sure all the bolts are nice and loose for the poor guy that got his job. Bush has single-handedly expanded migrant worker programs to depress wages and working conditions, opened our waterways to the dumping of waste from strip-mining coal companies, forced truckers to work fatally exhausting hours, exempted power plants from reducing their air pollution output in residential areas, sprouted horns and a crown of fire and has begun speaking in tongues.

Don’t believe me? Check out the piece in the Huffington Post by United Steelworkers International president Leo Gerard. Or Rupert Cornwell of The Independent. Both good.

These reactionary policies reveal the real value structure of the last eight years before Bush’s overdue curtain call. But then, maybe these are distractions from something really despicable going on behind the scenes, like if Bush is enriching his constituents who contribute nothing to society by plundering the taxpayers directly and not tracking the money – oh, right. That was just the bailout. No worries, then.

Bush’s midnight slurry of reactionary fascist programs will be challenging for Obama to reverse before their negative effects hit home, but I can sleep at night by telling myself they will at least be reversed. It’s tough to see a sea change in political sentiment, however, when the New Kid on the Block has declared himself as staunch an ally of Israel of, well, everyone since Truman. Israel’s policy of oppressing Palestinians into oblivion has somehow won our support. Rather than facilitating talks between our nuclear-armed ally and the diffused ethnic group they slap around, we’ve supplied Israel with arms and technology through the entire campaign of violence.

The current conflict in Gaza is no different. We stopped only short of decorating Olmert with the Medal of Freedom for his humanitarian work on resolving sectarian disputes through a successful war. Maybe there is some chance of change – Israel seems to be rushing their murderous territory-grab to get done before that wild card hits the Oval Office. I hope this Obama guy can get it right for once. Like when he wanted to legalize cannabis. Remember that?

We all should be throwing shoes. After Muntather Zaidi made the groundbreaking pitches, Bush should have been faced by more political shoe-tosses around every corner. The White House lawn should have been eclipsed by rogue footwear. Shoes should have joined “pretzels” “whistleblowersandformer terrorist allieson Bush’sto fear list. Make this year the year to speak your mind, break the mold and make changes for the better. There’s time left.

Certainly it is this year that allows for an unprecedented staging ground for a new world. The options are open. This could be a year of shortage, disorder and internecine competition between selfish nations resisting a global reordering, clinging to the failed and failing systems that have starved and impoverished the greater of humanity for centuries.

OR

We could take power into our own hands and build a world more compassionate and united, able to overcome the aggregated consequences of a legacy of incomprehension. The human soul will survive into the infinite if we become its caretakers and custodians. 2009 is here. Make it more than just a number.

 

CHEYA CARY wishes you luck on the resolutions you haven’t broken already. E-mail him at cheya.cary@gmail.com

Don’t Wait for Weight Loss

0

Thin is beautiful – and nowadays it seems thin is healthy, too.

We’re told an “obesity epidemic” of massive proportions is gripping the nation, and doctors are warning worried citizens about the dangers of being overweight – arthritis, heart disease, diabetes, cancer and more. More and more, the idea that thin equals healthy is being sold as by the media as common knowledge and established fact.

In Health at Every Size: The Surprising Truth About Your Weight published by BenBella Books, Dr. Linda Bacon, a UC Davis researcher and professor at San Francisco City College, sets out to debunk the myths surrounding weight. Using results from her research at UC Davis, she discusses how individuals can maintain a healthy lifestyle through the principles of Health at Every Size (HAES).

Working with What Works

Bacon makes it clear HAES isn’t about weight loss – it’s about healthy living. In her government-funded UC Davis study, Dr. Bacon and her colleagues recruited a total of 80 women – 40 of which participated in the HAES program and the other 40 of which underwent a conventional diet, which served as the control in the experiment. The women were middle aged, overweight and largely unhappy about their weight.

Each group met regularly for six months in groups of 10 women each.

“The diet group got the standard dieting message: exercise, eat healthy, lose weight. The HAES group got a different model,” Bacon explained. “We didn’t tell people they had to lose weight. We start with the opposite message, predicated on self-acceptance. [We tell them] this is the body you got – it’s not a sign of betrayal, it’s who you are, let’s celebrate it.”

The dieting control group would spend sessions talking about their weight, giving each other support. They would weigh in at the beginning of each session. Conversely, the HAES group was told their weights were not the issue (an initial disappointment for some, Bacon admits, because of an ingrained desire for weight loss). Instead, they would spend sessions discussing healthy habits in nutrition and movement.

“[Next] was body trust – if you are hungry, it’s your body saying you need nourishment … and movement is a celebration of the incredible body you have. We came up with much more creative ways to move … take the stairs, go to a further bathroom, go on a ‘walk and talk’ with your boss instead of a meeting in their office. The key is to make it part of your day.”

Participants were encouraged to keep eating journals to “read” and trust their bodies. Over time, participants could see patterns of food consumption, what types of food satisfied them and what types did not, what physical (as opposed to emotional) hunger felt like, and could recognize satiety (fullness).

“We innately know how much to eat. It’s hard for us to trust our bodies … when [participants] had high-sugar meals, they realized they were really hungry shortly after. But when they had a lot of fiber, they had a lasting sense of fullness. The idea was to recognize all the clues your body is giving to get the kinds of nutrients it needs,” Bacon said.

The HAES group was not told what and what not to eat, or to lose weight. The goal was simply, as Dr. Bacon put it, to “live in your body-to become embodied.”

 

Healthier and Happier on HAES

 

Bacon’s study was concluded two years later. The participants spent an entire year without any of the requirements dictated during their time in the study. When they came back to weigh in, their weight was the same. That was somewhat expected and disregarded – weight was never the issue.

Then, they measured objective health indicators – blood pressure and cholesterol, which, in the HAES group, were lowered considerably. More importantly to Bacon, individuals’ self-esteem and self-perception improved dramatically – they felt comfortable and healthy in their bodies regardless of weight.

“Healthy habits seemed to be the secret. All of this happened without a changing weight … [it showed] there is something really wrong, culturally, when we tell people it’s all about weight,” Bacon said.

The dieting group, on the other hand, experienced disappointing results. Weight, as well as health indicators, remained the same.

“Everything backslid – what was most depressing was the one thing that really worsened – self-esteem,” Bacon said. “And that’s what’s happening to people – they feel like failures, they feel lousy about themselves. We are pushing them into this model that makes them feel bad.”

The “D” Word is Dead

 

“None of this stuff that we commonly believe really works,” Bacon said. “And health myths with exercise are the same as myths with diets – [both say] if you exercise regularly everybody is going to be thin and happy. At first, the same thing happens – in the short term, almost all of them are successful … [but] the vast majority regain the weight that they lost.”

The bottom line: dieting – the big “D” – is dead. Research has shown that, contrary to the authoritative claims of late night infomercials, those pills, plans and exercise contraptions only help you lose money. And not only is dieting ineffective, it’s the wrong idea.

“[Dieting] is about depriving, which can set off all kinds of physiological backlashes. Very few people are able to do it and keep the weight off. The body is not set up to lose weight, it is set up to maintain weight,” said Sarah Josef, an adjunct professor at San Francisco State University who also teaches an HAES course at John F. Kennedy University in Pleasant Hill, Calif. “I’m a dietician – I used to teach weight management, and I watched people lose and gain and lose and gain and it was so frustrating. Working with HAES, I saw a difference in people being able to change their lifestyle and maintain it; they were healthier people and happier people.”

According to Bacon, Josef and others, even the idea of “overweight” is wrong, especially since those with moderately high body mass indices (BMI’s) have been shown, on average, to have longer life spans than “normal weight” people.

Cinder Ernst, a personal fitness trainer at Gold’s Gym in San Francisco and follower of HAES, knows from experience that the idea of “overweight” itself is harmful.

“Liking yourself isn’t easy in our world, in our society, at any size, but it’s especially not easy if you are bigger than what you “should” be. The word “overweight” is a judgment, you are judging somebody’s weight as over what you think it should be,” Ernst said.

 

Health and Happiness at Every Size

 

For college students, it’s a hard pill to swallow – many of us want to lose weight regardless, with health and well being as nothing but a false pretense. But in her book, Bacon asks her readers to reevaluate their values, their perceptions and their commitment to the health of their bodies.

“We need to acknowledge how difficult it is to live in a culturally stigmatized body,” she said. “Socially, we don’t accept them, we have stereotypical ideas about what they must have done to have that body. Honestly, we have to lighten up on other people, and not buy into all these cultural ideas of what’s attractive.”

Health at Every Size: The Surprising Truth About Your Weight, is an all-in-one: it serves as an exposition of Dr. Bacon’s research, a self-help book and a searing critique of a society that accepts a single standard of weight and equates that standard with health.

“Health has a lot of components,” Ernst said. “Fitness is one. Diet, as far as nutrition, is another. So is volunteering, family, community … [things] that we don’t address at all as a society. We’re too busy shooting Botox in our foreheads.”

For more information, visit the book’s website at haesbook.com. Health at Every Size is also available at the UC Davis bookstore.

 

ANDRE LEE can be reached at features@theaggie.org.

 

Daily Calendar

0

TODAY

Free lunch

11 a.m. to 1 p.m.

312 A St.

Econ 1A teaches there is no such thing as a free lunch. Watch Davis Christian Fellowship try and prove them wrong! Stop by for a free hot potato and make some new friends in 2009.

 

How to actually actualize your New Years resolution

5 to 6 p.m.

ARC Meeting Room 3

Learn how you can clarify and implement healthy resolutions and then learn how to stick to them!

 

Political history of development in Southern California

5:10 to 6:30 p.m.

1150 Hart Hall

Stephanie Pincetl, a UCLA professor, will speak in a lecture that is part of the History of California’s Landscapes series.

 

Food Addicts in Recovery Anonymous

7 to 8:30 p.m.

United Methodist Church, 1620 Anderson Road

This program is for individuals recovering from eating addictions, bulimia and under-eating based on the 12-step program from Alcoholics Anonymous. For more information, go to foodaddicts.org.

 

Visiting artist new work auditions

7 p.m.

185 Hickey Gym

Both dancers and non-dancers are invited to attend auditions for a new work by Granada Artist-in-Residence John Jasperse.

 

THURSDAY

An evening with Cree Edwards

6 to 8 p.m.

174 AOB IV

Edwards, the Chairman and CEO of eMeter corporation, will speak as a part of the UC Davis Sustainable Enterprise Speaker Series.

 

Super Smash Brothers Brawl tournament

6 to 10 p.m.

Griffin Lounge, MU

Go show your Brawl skills off during January’s video game tournament. I would recommend playing as Kirby, but don’t trust me! For more information, visit campusunions.ucdavis.edu or the Facebook group “I Love CU Programs!”

 

Thursday Trivia Nights

6 to 7:30 p.m.

Silo Union

Test your knowledge of random facts and potentially win fabulous prizes along the way!

 

Vet Aide Club

6:30 to 8:30 p.m.

2 Wellman

If you’re interested in veterinary medicine, come join the Vet Aide Club for information on the organization as well as for internship information. Internship applications and designs for club scrubs will be due at the meeting. For more information, please visit iccweb.ucdavis.edu/aes/vetaides.

 

TUESDAY

Relay for Life meeting

7 p.m.

106 Wellman

Learn how to make a difference and have a great time with friends at the Relay for Life captain meeting. You can even start your own team!

 

To receive placement in the AGGIE DAILY CALENDAR, e-mail dailycal@theaggie.org or stop by 25 Lower Freeborn by noon the day prior to your event. Due to space constraints, all event descriptions are subject to editing, and priority will be given to events that are free of charge and geared toward the campus community.

 

That’s what she said

0

I am a big fan of Tupac Shakur. I like his music and I like his style. Don’t stop reading this just because you don’t like rap music or think Tupac was overrated. Hear me out:

Rappers today have taken rap and watered it down. Raped it. While they might have the rhythm to sing along to a song with a lot of bass, their substance is absent. The have the means of reaching millions of people and yet write about things most people can’t relate to (mass amounts of money and multiple cars).

Tupac does this too sometimes. But (and this is aside from all the talk about “bitches” and “hoes,” which personally I don’t appreciate) there is an element of personality, honesty and skill in Tupac’s lyrics that won’t be found in any present day mainstream rappers. Listening to Tupac is like listening to your reminiscent grandfather tell you a long detailed story from the good old days. Except apparently they weren’t that great.

When Tupac talks about “Thug Life,” to me, he’s talking about the not-so-good old days. The fights, the struggles that some of us face in life. Through rage, poetry and bad manners he can express things that makes you either envy him or make you grateful for your own life. And I’m sure he’d be happy with either reaction.

What Tupac writes is like insight into his diary rather than something you can hump to in the club. Even when radio hits like “California Love” come on at a party, you realize you can’t really dance to it, but everyone definitely sings along. Am I right?

A lot of Tupac songs are about “the game,” money, women. And not in the best light. But even when he’s talking about things that rappers are stereotypically expected to rap on, he does it well. He writes it creatively and to a rhythm that today’s rappers can’t compare to. I’m not an expert in music and I definitely don’t have high standards for what I listen to, but even I can appreciate the way he expresses his words.

Like in his song “Death Around the Corner,” Tupac describes the environment he lived in: “Drinkin’ liquor out my momma’s titty/And smokin’ weed was an everyday thang in my household/And drinking liquor til’ you out cold./How many more jealous ass bitches, comin for my riches/ Now I gotta stay suspicious when I bone.”

And even though I don’t like his word choice about who he bones, so much more is being said than just “I’m a player and all the hunnies love me,” the common theme in today’s rap music. Tupac describes his distrust of women. Instead of claiming about how little he cares about “bitches” he uses the word “suspicious” (did you notice my own little rhyme there?) which connotes more a feeling of uneasiness than superiority. There are a lot of lyrics like this that can support my theory.

Another song that is revealing of Tupac’s sentiment is “Dear Mama,” which describes his appreciation for his mother and is apologetic for the hard times he’s given her: “And even as a crack fiend, Mama, you always was a black queen, Mama/I finally understand, for a woman it ain’t easy tryin’ to raise a man/You always was committed, a poor single mother on welfare/Tell me how you did it/There’s no way I can pay you back, but the plan is to show you that I understand.” His appreciation for his mother while acknowledging her flaws, to me, conveys his sincerity.

Lyrics from “Until the End of Time” that expresses his feelings for true friends while living in poverty: “But you could run to me when you need me, I’ll never leave/I just needed someone to believe in, as you can see/It’s a small thing through and true/What could I do? Real homies help you get through/And coming new, he’d do the same thing if he could.”

Lyrics like these can easily be overshadowed by his portrayal of the reality of poverty through violence, sex, drugs. But what Tupac says about these conditions is poetic and very honest. His lyrics show waves of emotion, anger, guilt, depression, that any person could feel. The “Thug Life” doesn’t necessary have to include guns and violence, everyone faces hard times, but staying true to yourself and doing what’s right is what’s important.

SARA KOHGADAI is a thug fo’ sho’. If you want to tell her about your own thug life or how you feel about Tupac’s version, e-mail her at sbkohgadai@ucdavis.edu.

 

State budget crisis leads to loan freeze

0

Mike Genest, director of the California Department of Finance, calls this the most challenging fiscal crisis California has ever faced. The California State Controller is projecting that California will be out of cash by February and the California Department of Finance is estimating a $40 billion budget deficit through the fiscal year of 2009-2010.

Mounting frustration onto an already difficult situation is the California state legislature’s inability to agree on a comprehensive budget plan. Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger has called the legislature’s failure to strike a compromise between Republicans and Democrats “unexcusable.”

As a result from the budget crisis and the lack of clear budget plans for the future, the state three-person Pooled Money Investment Board voted on Dec. 17 to halt billions of dollars worth of loans to finance state infrastructure projects.

“We are simply running out of options,” said Jacob Roper, deputy press secretary for the State Controller.

Tom Dresslar, director of communications for the State Treasurer said the state doesn’t have the money to do everything it needs.

“The pot of money that we use to provide financing for infrastructure projects is the same pot that is used to help support the general fund that provides money needed to operate a whole gamut of services: health care, education, social services, law enforcement, you name it,” Dresslar said. “And the problem is that we can’t continue both loaning money for infrastructure projects and supporting the general fund because of our budget situation. We don’t have the cash.”

There are an estimated 2,000 projects that will be affected by this loan freeze from schools to parks to prisons to levees.

The Natomas levee project is one such project that may be in jeopardy due to the lack of state funding. The Natomas levee system currently protects 80,000 citizens from the Sacramento River. However, evaluations of the levee concluded that conditions are so vulnerable that building permits for houses and businesses are not being issued until the levee is fixed.

“The levee is susceptible to deep underseepage,” said Jay Davis, the Sacramento Area Flood Control Agency consultant. “That’s when water penetrates from deep below the levee and of course, the number one importance is to correct that.”

The project is currently still moving forward, as state and local funding is enough to start construction set in April. But the total cost of the Natomas levee project is $618 million and while 10 percent is covered by local funds and 25 percent is covered by state funds, the remaining 65 percent still relies on funding from the federal government.

“Government funding is critical for the project,” Davis said.

For now, Davis remains optimistic.

“There’s concern if this budget crisis is prolonged of course, but it has currently not held up the project. It’s still moving full forward with the planning and design and issuing contracts and getting ready for our April construction.”

Other local projects are in jeopardy as well. According to the Sacramento Bee, funding for an expansion of the UC Davis Medical Center’s surgery and emergency center is in limbo. The project was originally expected to be completed in 2009. Additionally, nearly $1 million in funding for the Yolo Wayfarer Center, a homeless services provider, is also tied up.

The Pooled Money Investment Board plans to meet again later this month.

HELEN ZOU can be reached at city@theaggie.org.

Davis School Board approves prioritization of new Davis High stadium

0

Fundraisers such as the Dollar-A-Day campaign and Schoolapalooza, as well as the passage of Proposition W in November (a parcel tax specifically aimed at maintaining school programs), have helped to maintain funding for teachers, librarians and science programs.

Even with the extra money, some community members are still concerned about district finances.

The Davis Joint Unified School District board of trustees decided with a 4-1 vote to prioritize the building of a new stadium at Davis Senior High School as part of the new Facilities Master Plan at their Dec. 18 meeting.

“Metaphorically put in terms of baseball, the new stadium [Halden field] is not even on base, it’s at the plate because it has not yet been approved,” said Mike McDermott, Davis schools alumnus and president of the Blue and White Foundation, a non-profit organization dedicated to improving the high school.

Some parents and community members at Emerson Junior High School say the stadium should not be the top priority when repairs are desperately needed at their school.

Superintendent James Hammond addressed the issue of the reasoning for prioritizing the stadium rebuilding over other projects.

“Building the stadium is fiscally more feasible at this point,” said Superintendent Dr. James Hammond. “Emerson is structurally sound, but there do need to be updates in cooling and heating systems, along with refurbishing. This is one of the district’s priorities; it’s just that the stadium is best suited for plans now. There are already redevelopment funds from the county for the stadium remodel.”

Board president Gina Daleiden, who voted with the majority, told the Davis Enterprise that she believes “one project does not exclude another.”

McDermott, the foundation president, disagrees with those who think that the Emerson funding and the stadium funding are connected.

“Funding for the new field and Emerson are not connected. Emerson is funded by the general fund [paying for teachers, librarians, etc.], while the facility funds [paying for the building of new structures] are completely different,” McDermott said. “The stadium would make money for the school district as well because it would generate money for the general fund.”

Still some Emerson Junior High parents fear that the prioritization of the building of the new stadium at Davis High will leave the junior high under-funded, leading to its closure and consolidation with another school.

“Emerson should be the priority for funding,” Emerson parent and Chipotle owner Joe Herman said. “It’s neglected and old. They talked about closing it last year, and with the funding going to the new stadium it’s an excuse to ignore the situation at Emerson. There isn’t even a bus system for these students, so they’d have to ride their bikes across town.”

The Board of Education and superintendent clearly disagree with those who think that Emerson’s closure is imminent if modernization of the school is not prioritized as highly as the stadium.

Hammond also addressed the possibly of Emerson being closed last year, a major reason for fear among those who oppose the building of the stadium.

“The closure last year of Emerson was simply a discussion in consideration of balancing the budget. There are no hidden agendas in the building of the stadium,” Hammond said.

With controversy over where funds would come from, there are also certain restrictions on which sources can be used to fund the project.

“An oversight committee comprised of the general public is charged with insuring that parcel tax monies are used properly,” said Yes on W campaign manager Kingsley Melton. “The W money would not be used for the building of the stadium, as it would be a misuse and have disastrous consequences for any future parcel tax campaign.”

Some see other reasons for the building as justified.

“The priority of the school district should always be to provide the best education possible. [That said], education doesn’t always happen in the classroom,” Melton said.

“Other schools won’t even play on the field because the conditions are so bad. There’s safety issues as well,” McDermott said.

Even with administrators receiving raises during the financial crisis, there are loopholes that make it hard to avoid the extra expenditures.

“The school board should not approve expenditures it doesn’t have the money for, but if the raises were approved before the budget woes there’s nothing you can do,” Melton said.

In the Davis Enterprise, trustee Tim Taylor expressed concern about the “constant pitting of Davis against Davis” when facilities projects are discussed. “For every program that gets a voice of support, there’s another program or group or constituency that comes out in opposition…. I’d like to hope that as a community, we can get past that.”

Funding for the potential new stadium will be discussed at the Jan. 8 Board of Education meeting.

ANGELA SWARTZ can be reached city@theaggie.org.

 

College students abuse prescription ADHD medication

0

Many college students are using prescription ADHD medication such as Ritalin or Adderall to improve their academic performance, according to a new study.

“The study was prompted by anecdotal reports from students about usage,” said coauthor Scott Swartzwelder, a Duke University professor. “My understanding is that the trend is relatively new and escalating.”

The study surveyed 3,407 students from all demographics without a prescription for ADHD medication at University of North Carolina at Greensboro and Duke University.

The study showed that 8.8 percent of students at Greensboro and 9 percent of students at Duke admitted to having used ADHD for non-medical reasons during their college years. Although data was taken from only one public university and one private university, the findings were consistent with previous surveys on the subject.

The study showed that 89 percent of students surveyed who had used ADHD medication for non-medical reasons said they were able to better concentrate while studying and studied longer after taking ADHD medication.

The study showed that students who were Caucasian and belonging to a fraternity or sorority were more likely to use ADHD drugs for non-medical purposes. These students also tended to have lower GPAs and were more likely to have abused other substances. The study showed that most students obtained the medication from another student with a prescription.

Wayne Salo, chief of psychiatry for Counseling and Psychological Services at UC Davis, said abuse of ADHD medication is dangerous.

“ADHD is a psychiatric disorder originating in childhood and often continuing into adulthood,” Salo said. “ADHD medication is not a substitute for poor study skills or lack of motivation and can be dangerous.”

Estimates of adults that suffer from ADHD range from 3 to 5 percent. According to Salo, common side effects of ADHD medication can include insomnia, irritability, headaches, suppressed appetite, higher blood pressure and even death in those who have cardiac problems. Psychiatric disorders and anorexia can also worsen with use of ADHD medication.

“The studies of long-term side effects are minimal,” Swartzwelder said. “These drugs do improve alertness and allow the student to study for longer periods of time, and with better concentration. That said, the overall balance of effectiveness and risk is probably not worth it.”

Seventy percent of students who reported having used ADHD medication for non-medical reasons ranked the overall impact of use as positive or very positive.

“It is interestingly analogous to the use of ‘performance-enhancing’ drugs in athletics,” Swartzwelder.

Brian Dodson, a junior at UC Davis, says he has used Adderall in the past for non-medical reasons.

“For me, it was advantageous in doing monotonous and boring things,” he said. “It helps you focus more, but it definitely does not supply you with more brain power or anything. You might make more flash cards if you use it.”

RONNY SMITH can be reached at city@theaggie.org.

UC Davis winemaking equation disputed by new paper

0

A long-standing method for determining tannin levels in wine developed at UC Davis is being challenged by an outside research group.

Larry Brooks of LM Brooks Consulting published a study that claims to invalidate the Adams-Harbertson tannin assay, developed at UC Davis by Dr. Doug Adams and Dr. Jim Harbertson. The assay is a scientific method for tracking tannin concentration in wine.

Tannins, which are astringent, bitter plant polyphenols that bind or precipitate proteins, cause the dry and puckery sensation in the mouth after drinking red wine or unripe fruit.

The 1999 Adams-Harbertson tannin assay was adapted for wine from the original 1978 Hagerman-Butler method, a protein precipitation-based tannin method applied in ecology and grain tannin.

“We didn’t really publish the paper to develop a method,” said Adams, professor at the UC Davis department of viticulture and enology. “We used a method that has been used since 1978. [The assay] has been used in other fields and has been used for around 30 years. It’s a well-accepted method. All we did was adapt it for wine.”

According to the paper by Brooks refuting the assay, “an extensive invalidation of the assay results with luxury wine data shows that the assay cannot distinguish bottled wine with reasonable accuracy.”

Adams, however, said that there is a distinction to be made – the paper does not document a validity test but a competency test of the labs.

“[Brooks] didn’t really conduct a test on the assay itself,” Adams said. “He sent wines to different labs and got different numbers. What you will see is there is no data that talks about validity of the assay but different labs’ ability to test.”

Brooks works as an independent consultant in the wine business in winegrowing and winemaking. When one of his winemaking clients wanted to start using this assay, Brooks had doubts about its accuracy and precision.

“Before I could recommend the client start using this assay as a decision making tool I wanted to validate it using standard protocols,” said Brooks in an e-mail interview. “In these protocols different labs are sent blind coded samples of wines to analyze. If the results are in agreement within certain parameters the analysis is considered valid.”

Brooks had four winery labs and one commercial lab in California use the Adams-Harbertson to assay nine replicates of three bottled wines available in California supermarkets.

“Our study found that this assay had unacceptable variation in results both within and between laboratories. We were not able to validate [the assay],” Brooks said.

In a written statement by UC Davis, Andrew Waterhouse, chair of the viticulture & enology department, said that like any analytical procedure, the Adams-Harbertson assay requires time and effort to ensure that a lab or analyst can deliver reproducible results.

“Regular comparisons of routine assays between winery labs show large variations – up to 20 percent in some cases,” he said. “So Brooks’ study would appear to re-substantiate this common occurrence rather than invalidate the tannin assay.”

Adams said UC Davis does not have plans to review its research.

“The reason we don’t have any inclination to go back and take a look at it is because we have to write research grants,” he said. “It would be difficult to get research money [when] the method is well accepted and used for lots for other things, like in ecology.”

Brooks does not believe the Harbertson-Adams assay should be utilized for basic research in winegrowing and winemaking.

“I think that the desire to have an inexpensive winery-operated analysis for tannin is a valid goal,” he said. “I would love to see it achieved. I don’t think we are there yet, and don’t believe that this assay works for this.”

Brooks co-authored the paper with Leo McCloskey and Doug McKesson from Enologix, a Sonoma based consulting company, and Marshall Sylvan from UC Santa Cruz. It appeared in the September 2008 issue of the Journal of the Association of Official Analytical Chemists.

 

POOJA KUMAR can be reached at campus@theaggie.org.